Here is the list of priests who have served at Annunciation through the years:
- Fr. Meinrad M. McCarty, OSB
- Fr. Benedict Brunet, OSB
- Fr. H. Pierrard
- Fr. Joseph T. Bauer
- Fr. A. J. Rawlinson
- Fr. David Fitzgerald
- Fr. Fredric Burget (Administrator)
- Fr. A. G. Wicke
- Fr. J. F. Patterson
- Fr. Charles Wagner
- Fr. Charles McSween
- Fr. Anthony Spicuzza
- Fr. Kenneth Ciano
- Fr. Robert Hausladen
- Fr. Stephen Jarrell
- Fr. Dominic Chukwudi
- Fr. Harold W. Rightor II
- and our current pastor - Fr. John Hollowell
